Deafening Silence

Why the deafening silence from African artists and musicians following the murder of gay activist David Kato?

David Kato.

This Is Africa points out that musicians are usually the first to speak out on behalf of the underdog. But not if you are lesbian or gay, apparently. Media houses are usually the first to complain when they’re the subject of censorship. Again, with the media it seems freedom of speech is a value that is only sometimes worth protecting. The Ugandan newspapers, “The East African” and “Monitor” have refused to run an advertisement paying tribute to David Kato, Uganda’s first openly gay man and at the head of many of the gay rights struggles there before he was murdered on January 26th, 2011. The ad in The East African and The Monitor was to be paid for by my colleagues at Open Society Institute of Eastern Africa. The publishing houses wanted some of the text “toned down,” which OSIEA refused to do.

Kudos then to British-born R&B singer, Marsha Ambrosius, for her recent video against homophobia.

It tells the story of a black gay couple who are socially shunned, and jointly commit suicide. Congratulations to Ambrosius for speaking out (see the props here from Colorlines).

The messaging, however, is a little clumsy. For one, it did not need the monologue by Ambrosius at the end. The song and the video stand on their own. Neither is the reference by Ambrosius to “alternative lifestyles” helpful. Finally, since the video clearly has a social message, surely it would have been smarter to depict a couple overcoming prejudice rather than succumbing to it in such a stylish manner?

Further Reading

The battle over the frame

As Hollywood recycles pro-war propaganda for Gen Z, Youssef Chahine’s ‘Djamila, the Algerian’ reminds us that anti-colonial cinema once turned imperial film language against its makers—and still can.

Fictions of freedom

K. Sello Duiker’s ‘The Quiet Violence of Dreams’ still haunts Cape Town, a city whose beauty masks its brutal exclusions. Two decades later, in the shadow of Amazon’s new development, its truths are more urgent than ever.

When things fall apart

Against a backdrop of global collapse, one exhibition used Chinua Achebe’s classic to hold space for voices from the Global South—and asked who gets to imagine the future.

The General sleeps

As former Nigerian president Muhammadu Buhari’s death is mourned with official reverence, a generation remembers the eight years that drove them out.

The grift tank

In Washington’s think tank ecosystem, Africa is treated as a low-stakes arena where performance substitutes for knowledge. The result: unqualified actors shaping policy on behalf of militarists, lobbyists, and frauds.

Kagame’s hidden war

Rwanda’s military deployments in Mozambique and its shadowy ties to M23 rebels in eastern Congo are not isolated interventions, rather part of a broader geopolitical strategy to expand its regional influence.

After the coups

Without institutional foundations or credible partners, the Alliance of Sahel States risks becoming the latest failed experiment in regional integration.