The artist Alfredo Jaar has said that “we are the sum of all the stimuli we receive,” and certainly images, whether in the form of illustrations, videos or photographs, make up an influential portion of that stimuli. In a world plagued by mass shootings, hate crimes, and the stubborn persistence of a range of discriminatory -isms, perception of social difference is critical for determining the relationships we have with each other.
Another Way Home, on view at Open Society Foundations in New York contemplates the impacts of images in our lives. The exhibition is part of the Moving Walls series, an initiative of the Open Society Documentary Photography Project, which has been sharing socially-relevant documentary practice for 20 years. As the 25th iteration of Moving Walls, Another Way Home takes on the issue of migration by featuring eight projects created by 13 artists from around the world. The exhibition, co-curated by Yukiko Yamagata and Siobhan Riordan, can be viewed online or anyone in New York can view it onsite until July 2019 at Open Society Foundations’ New York offices.
Working through the mediums of video, mural, newspaper and various modes of photography, each of the bodies of work offers nuanced interpretations of how migration effects families, communities and individuals—those who travel and those who stay behind. Whether through fashion photography representing African migrants as regal or virtual reality film deployed as a means to reunite families, the artists in Another Way Home bring to the fore a kaleidoscopic array of perspectives that, in the past, have existed outside the frame of images recording migrants and migration. Indeed, one of the central elements of the Moving Walls selection process is demonstration of immersive connection with people and places featured in the works. Through those strong relationships, the nerve channels that link people to ideas of home are experienced and documented intimately by the artists.
Immense power rests with those who are the creators of art and media. This power may manifest in different ways, ranging from exploitation to cooperation. Having considered the contact zones of image-power associated with the exhibition holistically, Siobhan Riordan, Project Head of the Documentary Photography Project, remarked to me that “a big question that impacts every part of an exhibition down to the curatorial framework and process itself is, how do you decentralize power and whose voices are at the table every step of the way?”
One critical manner in which the question of power has been incorporated relates to how language is presented. In both the exhibition space and in the accompanying catalog, the languages of the people featured in each project—in this case Spanish and Arabic—are privileged over English as primary languages. English translations of project descriptions are available, though in situ you must actually lift the sheet of paper containing the primary language to see English text revealed beneath. In the catalog, the primary languages are encountered first and the book must be turned upside down on the following pages for English to be read. These physical interventions can be seen as ephemeral simulations of migratory experience and they act as reorientations of language hierarchy.
At the level of the artists’ practice, when documentary works such as those featured in Another Way Home are generated through ongoing conversation and co-creation, the power embedded in art and media is distributed and the works more effectively represent the stories of the people being depicted. Within the exhibition, the project, Welcome to Intipucá City, displays portraits of people and domestic spaces in El Salvador juxtaposed with hand-drawn family trees indicating who has or has not migrated. Powerfully, some of the family trees and portraits indicate only a single family member remaining in El Salvador, while images of homes reveal the marks of United States American culture on the landscape. The artists behind the project, Jessica Ávalos, Koral Carballo and Anita Pouchard Serra, speak to bridging the distance between viewers and subjects of their work:
We live in contexts where audiences read less and less and opt for viral and content-poor publications. Images are powerful elements that allow us to approach that audience saturated with content and bring them closer to the protagonists.
The sentiment of closeness can also be found in The Right to Grow Old, a project by Honduran photojournalist Tomas Ayuso. This project offers a poetic collection of images from Honduras, Mexico and the United States tracing the resilient lives of Honduran migrants in different stages of their journeys towards security, as they experience physical and social borders along the way. On the impact of images, Ayuso says:
With images that depict current issues in an in-depth manner we can develop empathy and understanding. Sometimes images become clarion calls and trigger social movements into action. Images that tell stories are crucial not only in societies, but at the local level and down to the individual.
Though it exists permanently online, the exhibition itself could benefit from a few more public showings and events that would challenge new audiences to confront the works. Moving Walls does however go beyond a static show as the artists behind each of the projects are also given a Fellowship grant to continue their existing project or develop a new body of work. This aspect of Moving Walls is particularly powerful as it circulates their work outside the limitations of the gallery space, resourcing the artists to enhance the impact of their social practice, engaging further with their respective communities through their own public programming, book production, additional research and immersive content creation.
Through its adroitly designed display of documentary projects—which are accompanied by detailed information and captions, often with reflections from those appearing in images—the Another Way Home exhibition is effective in challenging the dominant regimes of knowledge that disparage migrants and migration. The projects in the show work to collapse distance and deepen the awareness viewers have of people in different migration contexts. Indeed, it is not images themselves which brand people as immigrants or refugees, rather, that work is performed by ideological discourse deployed for political means. Depending on what preconceptions about migration issues viewers bring to the exhibition, the depth and care infused into the works can operate in different registers for conveying representation, critical (un)learning, and expanding and reshaping the internal image indexes that guide how we interpret the world around us. In this way, Another Way Home represents a model contemporary media initiative, as it transcends the exhibition walls by encouraging us to reflect on how the images we encounter affect us, how we see each other and ultimately, how we may live together.